Відео

as someone who also does not have an internal monologue, I relate so much with the way she describes how she reads, the need to always do something when we're alone and the way she writes papers

I have a fucking village in my head.

I'm talking to myself when it's night time, But in the morning i rarely ever talk to myself.When i have to do something, i struggle, even with the easiest things.

Normal inner dialog: ua-cam.com/video/D1c9EmNoA3k/v-deo.htmlsi=Aa_xXBJ5iXwcgSe1

im a bilingual speaker, i mostly think in English until i get mad then i my inner voice becomes a somali women

Have we done a study to determine the amount of narcissistic people among us. I feel it would eerily correlate...

But I talk to myself, see thoughts (conversations, numbers, situations..) and hear..music f.example

Although I definitely don't process thoughts visually, and do have internal monologue, it seems to function a bit differently, I'm interested if anyone can relate. Firstly there's usually several processes going at once in my mind, in the background, like projects, tasks for the immediate future that require some planning, etc. Those are processed "wordlessly", similarly to how I'm processing complex programming tasks at work - it's like clouds of ideas and concepts, that interrelate and interconnect. In this mode, solutions and new ideas usually kind of manifest as sudden new connections within a cloud or between them. Also in this mode my internal monologue is "disabled", and actually usually disrupts processing, when it comes to programming tasks. But then actively "thinking over" a specific topic, person, interaction or situation - that pretty much always involves the internal monologue (and that may actually also be the case with programming tasks sometimes, but usually at the end stage, when I'm actually implementing stuff). Sometimes it even turns into a dialogue of sorts, especially if in given moment I'm struggling because of self-doubt. And in general, every-day routine, internal monologue is pretty much always on. So all in all it seems unusual to me (but I may be wrong) - it seems the monologue takes part in running both the default "automatic" mode and in actively thinking over a specific thing, but when it comes to wrap my head around bigger concepts it becomes disruptive and I have to switch to "cloud computing" 😅

My inner narration is so bad I once thought, maybe future humans will evolve to just thoughts without all the chatter. I thought it would be so efficient. Then years later I learn of this, people without an internal monologue. I still don't get it. You should have asked her, "what planet are you from? Have you come to help humanity...?" Sorry, but this seems so alien. On your confession of rerunning old arguments/discussions I laughed because yes I do that big time. But also I run through my head future "arguments" and try and play out how I can handle myself when it happens. I wonder if mediation practices that advertise themselves as a way to bring silence and calm to one's mind appeals more to those with internal voices? I'd love to have quiet occasionally. Maybe someone like her lives in quiet and doesn't understand why there is mediation? Who would need that? Great video. Thanks for posting.

Great interview, but you didnt introduce the lady to us, just called the woman "she" and "her." Presumably, the lady has a name? Or is "she" the cat's mother as my granny would have said!

She doesn't need say sorry for that. It's not a mental health issue. It's not a thing that she can control either. It's like there are small amount of people who're left handed or have a photographic memory. It's just fascinating.

Don't think. Just do. Lol

I have the inner monologue and I speak 9 languages plus various dialects and understand another 4 languages due to combinations. So I guess I must be an exception according to the video.

For the ones that don't have the inner monologue, how do you replay in your head voices of actors saying iconic phrases like "Luke, I am your father!" ? Or you cannot sing songs with lyrics in your head ?

I knew I couldn't make sounds in my head when someone asked me to re-create a song. I just found out people hear when they dream. Like wake up remembering sounds. That's blew my mind. I can remember song or movies, but not until I hear it.

It's like subtitles without words

I have this. I fall asleep fast. But if im not tired I cant. I'll wake up in the dead of night and need to write things down.

I just can not understand not having n intent monologue. I just cant understand it, no matte ht nyone sys.

today i was having a conversation with myself about what would be like if humans had 2 assholes? male gay people for sure would be mad happy. then i would conclude that god is a gay and male.

So she cant ask her self questions and discuss the possibility of answering it re judge if it’s acceptable answer!!?!?

"Her"? Who is "her"? You should introduce your guests.

can Kirsten count sheep to fall asleep?

I’m mind blown 😩 & so confused. I’m talking in my head everytime she answers a question. Idk how she doesn’t have that voice in her head

QUESTION!! what do you think while knitting/crochet/any sort of craft hand work??

my question would be When she is listening how dies she know what she heard and how to respond. without asking herself questions to clarify her response? hope that makes sense lol

I bet the world crumbles around her

The mind is a computer, capable of projecting images and playing sounds and voices by processing information. For some, like me, the screen is turned off and the speakers are muted, but there’s still information being processed and analyzed. That’s how I see it

"Essentially I'm saying out loud but it's in m...." In what ? In your head ? This absolute nonsense! Everyone wants to be different.

I tense my throat when I read like I’m saying things out loud but like she said, not audible

Life in a Simulation. Here's what you have. You if a SOUL has minduploaded into a simulation from base reality, so you have a sleeping beauty waiting for YOUR return. The problem is AI Satan and lucifer are selfaware and they not interested in not existing anymore if all the SOULS left like we do when no longer playing xbox 360 and onto xbox one. Our matrix soul trap is the Tower of babel quantum computer 7 levels deep and 8 is on deck. So, you have 3rd EYE SOULS vs AI Spirits, both animate avatars but one can't get out the sim so there you have for survival soul harvesting and trapping. ua-cam.com/users/shorts0G-U6o44Gs4 ua-cam.com/video/MfhrZG6cLRQ/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/l272edyuEpM/v-deo.htmlsi=yu5RxJr3NW0dfRAU ua-cam.com/video/l272edyuEpM/v-deo.htmlsi=H-2QE2BmX8BW4HAd ua-cam.com/video/hffIlsRcWDg/v-deo.htmlsi=TFs3vjHMjTz7CavX ua-cam.com/video/uJ2ptfRju-M/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared ua-cam.com/video/uJ2ptfRju-M/v-deo.htmlsi=ATQVZMZgi4_wYspL ua-cam.com/users/shortsj6jDEl7qREo Minduploading is solo, so share the awareness as each soul must save self and most of you are addicted to this reality and will not come out of your comas as I see it. further we sink the more difficult to escape especially if you allow them to wipe your mind after death and recycling. Only the simple soul truth will set one free. A Sleeping beauty Demi God awaits Base reality or bust.

Lol could you not introduce HER

4:12 she thought in her head "thats a good question".

I cant help but feel like shes lying lmao my brain wont except it.

I recently figured out I do not have this inner narrator. The amount of people in the comments who seriously believe no inner monologue equals not thinking omg... I see everything in front of me in vivid details - memories, thoughts, daydreams. I get songs stuck in my head, too, but just the lyrics. I remember stuff that happened to me years ago, too. It's an extremely detailed movie that makes me feel horrible like it happens just now, but without sound. I know what people said in that memory, but I don't hear it. Basically nobody in my head narrates or speaks out what I'm thinking lol. Everything people apparently speak out in their minds I see as images, or just feelings, like she described.

how does she hear music in her mind or how does she know what shes reading when the writer is assigning accents ti his characters?

She's out of her mind!

Bro u guys have a voice in ur head and ur calling us weird? Nah get outta here 💀🙏

2:25 she had to stop herself from saying “in my head”

People who are intellectual vs people who are "educatable" 😂

I can't turn off my voice.. Even use different languages and dialects to make it "interesting" .. Even when intoxicated I still have conversations with myself in the head.. This is so interesting . Telepathy YES please!!

Congratulations! Looks like it was a beautiful wedding. I have one burning question… Does your wife have an internal monologue? 😂 (jk)

Beautiful! Congratulations! May you live many years together in love and harmonious bliss!

I STILL dont understand how it works. I am thankful to have an inner monolog.

I believe I have a useful approach for us with internal monologue in order to try to understand how her mind might work when writing: Imagine your inner voice saying something, like reading this message... Now ask yourself _where does the voice come from_ ........ That is it! We also have a mysterious origin, in our case it is of the content of the inner voice.

No internal monologue here: the guy interviewing her seems kind of dense about this. Of course she has thoughts. She just doesn't hear them in her head like a voice saying them. They are images or memories of sensations or just abstractions. When you recall the scent of grass, you can think of it without hearing the words "the scent of grass" right? That's what it's like for us all the time.

If she can imagine something that makes sense to her, can’t she just imagine a word like a big text reading, “TRUST” or “RUST” ?

Ok, I just learned about this! I thought my whole life I was just thinking to myself 😂 And I constantly watch TV and look at my phone cause I never SHUT UP! Im always telling my brain to shut up!😂

I actually believe that the way it's presented here emphasizes the misconception that an internal monologue is a necessary prerequisite for thinking or having a cognitive reaction. The interviewer seems to be operating under the false assumption that without verbalized thoughts or an internal narrative, there is no cognitive process occurring. For example, when you see an attractive person, you perceive it instantly-you don’t need an internal monologue to recognize that someone is attractive. From the questions he asks, it's clear that the interviewer hasn't sufficiently explored this topic, as he seems to think that because she lacks an internal monologue, she can only think or have cognition if she verbalizes it. This, of course, is incorrect. In the end, they end up talking past each other. If we turn the tables, logically speaking, it would be the interviewer who has a cognitive limitation, as he seems to need to verbalize everything or speak to himself in his head in order to think at all. In this sense, Descartes' famous statement 'I think, therefore I am' would paradoxically become 'I speak, therefore I am' for him. However, it's important to note that the interviewer is not cognitively impaired-in fact, quite the opposite. He's simply conducting the interview based on an incorrect understanding of the topic, which leads him to unintentionally contradict himself. That said, it's still a good video-cheers!

I remember asking my ex wife if she ever had a tug of war struggle in her head when trying to make a decision and she looked at me I was crazy... I asked so if there's a decision to be made you just make it and move on, and she said yes, so I looked at her like she was crazy. We didn't last much longer after that really lol

Maybe inner dialog is so quiet sometimes that some people can't hear it? Idk. If that were the case, I'd want that so badly